Dear Site Visitors:
Welcome to Twi-Fic Reviews! It’s our pleasure to introduce a site where readers can rate and review Twilight fan fiction, as well as find completed stories to read. Twi-Fic Reviews is meant to be a respectful and spoiler-free zone where you can give your honest opinions about stories you’ve read.
Just so you know, reviews/comments are moderated, which means your comments may not appear on the site for up to 24 hours. Don’t worry, we’ll get to it! The reason for the moderation is to insure that reviews do not contain spoilers or inflammatory language. Twi-Fic Reviews is not meant to be a forum in which the merits of a story are debated. There are tons of places for that. We just want to know what you think about a story; your opinion will guide other readers when deciding what to read.
Please note that authors are not allowed to review or comment on their own stories. This is because we already know what an author thinks of his or her own work (that it’s fantabulous). Also, we want reviewers to give their honest critique of a story without worrying about offending or angering the author.
Finally, Twi-Fic Reviews does not provide copies of stories to readers. In an effort to avoid all possible copyright issues, we simply provide links to the site where the author has chosen to post his/her story.
So go get rating and reviewing because there won't be any story ratings to help you make a choice about what to read next -- unless readers like you take the time to submit reviews. Remember to invite your friends to take advantage of the site, too.
--Twi-Fic Reviews Admin Team
For more info, visit the FAQs page
I can’t really recommend this story. It’s quite well written and the author has some talent, but I have a really hard time with stories set in the past which give no account WHATSOEVER to the mores and attitudes of those times. This is 19th century Paris, but it has middle-class Carlisle and Esme, Edward’s parents, with no servants and allowing their unmarried teenage daughter to not only spend unchaperoned time with her lover, Jacob, but be completely unfazed by the fact they are having sex. A girl of Rosalie’s class would be ruined by such behaviour. Also, the author is a musician, and he has Edward compose a song for Bella which would be more at home in the 1980s.
In the end I had to stop reading – if authors want to write a modern love story, then do so. But if you want to write a period piece, then do the research – in this day and age of the internet it really isn’t that hard to at least give a passing nod to historical accuracy.